Which Consumer Staples ETF Is the Better Buy: Fidelity's FSTA or iShares' IYK?

Fidelity's FSTA ETF offers a significantly lower expense ratio of 0.08% compared to iShares' IYK at 0.38%, while delivering stronger five-year returns ($1,401 vs $1,370 on $1,000 invested). FSTA holds 104 stocks with pure consumer staples focus, whereas IYK holds 53 stocks with broader diversification including healthcare and basic materials. For most long-term investors, FSTA's lower costs and better performance make it the more practical choice, though IYK appeals to those seeking higher dividend yield (2.5% vs 2.2%) and sector diversification.